100% Locally Owned, Independent and Free

100% Locally Owned, Independent and Free

Services cut but retirement village closure put on hold over legal challenge

Do you have a news tip? Click here to send to our news team.

Region among hardest hit by melanoma

Hundreds of Sunshine Coast residents have been diagnosed with melanoma in a single year, with Cancer Council Queensland identifying the region as one of More

New French bakery replaces prominent beachside cafe

A Sunshine Coast couple behind some of the region's favourite bakeries are opening a new venue in a beach town, taking over a site More

Consultation underway on next stage of bypass

Public feedback is being sought on the next phase of key road project, including new lanes and changes to a busy intersection. The state government More

Free business courses project in running for national award

A Sunshine Coast university initiative that has helped more than 2000 Queensland small and family businesses has been recognised as a finalist in a More

Jane Stephens: sleighing online shopping

There was a time when Christmas shopping was relatively simple. You wandered into Sunshine Plaza with a list of people to buy for and went More

Challenging property market proves fruitful on Coast

A leading Sunshine Coast property group said softer market conditions had created opportunities for strategic property investment. Mooloolaba-based property company Rafter Myers has secured a More

The closure of a retirement village has been put on hold following concerns that its elderly residents could suffer “irreversible harm” without improved relocation assistance.

Six residents of Seasons Caloundra at Golden Beach challenged a decision by the Department of Housing and Public Works to approve a plan for the village to cease operating as a supported living community and transition to a rental-only model.

The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal has now ‘stayed’ that decision, meaning the closure cannot proceed until the residents’ review application is addressed.

The stay was granted on June 16 by QCAT member Noel Jensen, who found the review should first consider whether the approved closure plan provided a “clear, orderly and fair process” as required under the Retirement Villages Act.

“The purpose of the review application is not to prevent the closure of the village; it is to seek a direction that the closure plan be revised to offer significantly improved assistance to residents to find alternate accommodation,” the ruling states.

“If the plan is implemented, then this opportunity will be lost to the applicants.”

The department approved Seasons’ proposed closure plan on March 14, and on March 18 the operator informed residents it would remove services such as the community bus and lifestyle program from March 28 and emergency call system from April 11.

The six residents – including Margaret Ross, whose family spoke out on the planned changes last year – lodged their appeal to review the decision and for a stay on March 27.

They argued a stay would not be an “unreasonable inconvenience” for Seasons because the village had already largely transitioned to a rental tenancy agreement model, with only six out of 120 apartments having a 99-year retirement lease tenure.

“It is submitted that this (enacting the closure) will cause irreversible harm to the residents who are seeking a direction that the closure plan be revised to offer significantly improved assistance,” the appeal documents state.

Six residents have appealed changes made at this seniors living community.

“Significantly increased assistance will be required to allow the affected residents, who are in the last stages of their lives, to find alternate, secure accommodation close to their family, friends and critical support networks.”

Seasons argued a stay order would cause it significant cost and inconvenience, including more than $90,000 to reinstate the community bus, $10,000 to restart the lifestyle program plus $15,000 annually, and up to $221,000 to restore the emergency call system plus ongoing costs.

It also claimed cutting the services would have minimal daily impact on the applicants, noting several had replaced the emergency call system, one had moved out, another was no longer suitable for independent living and others had alternative transport arrangements.

Help us deliver more news by registering for our FREE daily news feed. All it requires is your email at the bottom of this article.

The ruling notes the department did not oppose the stay.

“The first respondent (Department of Housing and Public Works) submits that while the RV Act cannot prevent the closure of a scheme, it can direct change to the closure plan,” it says.

“Without the stay, the review proceedings will possibly be rendered futile as the second respondent (Seasons) will not be prevented from implementing the currently approved closure plan.”

The tribunal ruled the applicants could suffer “irremediable harm” if the stay was not granted.

“In my view, the public interest is better served by ensuring that the requirements of the RV Act are able to be reviewed by the tribunal without change to the status quo, rather than allowing the second respondent to close the scheme and cancel the leases of the remaining residents before the review application is heard and determined by the tribunal,” the ruling states.

However, Seasons is not required to reinstate the community bus service, lifestyle program or emergency call system.

“I find it to be to be an unreasonable commercial requirement to place on the second respondent in these circumstances,” the ruling states.

Subscribe to SCN’s free daily news email

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
[scn_go_back_button] Return Home
Share