100% Locally Owned, Independent and Free

100% Locally Owned, Independent and Free

Jane Stephens: how would states keep books in black without profiting from our vices?

Do you have a news tip? Click here to send to our news team.

Tribunal delays retirement village closure for review

The closure of a retirement village has been put on hold following concerns that its elderly residents could suffer “irreversible harm” without improved relocation More

Huge new ‘gompa’ proposed for hinterland retreat

One of Australia’s most prominent Buddhist centres has lodged plans for a new central meditation hall – or ‘gompa’ – at its sprawling Sunshine More

‘Risky’ parking spaces prompts call for accessibility audit

Residents are backing a call for a review of accessible parking options, claiming poorly designed spaces create an “unacceptable risk” for all road users. The More

Ashley Robinson: level of pain on another plane

I have a couple of allergies. I am dead-set allergic to pain, which sort of makes sense that I am scared of dentists. It all More

‘Tough spot’: why cup of coffee could soar to $10

A blend of cost-of-living pressures and an increase in demand for one of the world’s biggest commodities could bump up the price of a More

High-tech trolleys to be rolled out at major supermarket

Shoppers at a major supermarket will have a “revolutionary” way to purchase groceries, with the introduction of new high-tech trolleys. Woolworths is set to introduce More

Taxes are a government strategy to control the masses.

They are designed to rein in our bad behaviours by making them costly, but they also create a river of gold for the government coffers.

An inalienable truth is that our government relies on our vices to pay its bills.

They need us to keep gambling, smoking and boozing or their books would fall into the red. They need us to break laws to adequately fill their coffers.

It seems unconscionable.

To avoid the sting at the cash register, people find workarounds.

Remember when the government felt the best way to deter youngies from binge drinking was to tax the wazoo out of so-called alcopops? It just meant drinkers went for straight spirits (much cheaper) and did their own reckless mixing.

Where nicotine products are concerned, the high tax approach has simply built a booming black market.

The Australian Association of Convenience Stores say illegally imported cigarettes now account for 40 per cent of the market, and as many as 92 per cent of the still-pervasive vapes in the country are illegally sourced.

Now it has been revealed that taxing smokes to the hilt has created a steady source of income for fierce and violent organised crime gangs and made criminals of the poor and the addicted.

Wicked motivation plus spurious action equals terrible outcome.

Taxes have a friend in fines as a favoured government control mechanism.

Ratcheting up the fine for touching your phone while driving ($1209) has whacked offenders harder than a prize fighter.

I know too many who have been snapped at an inopportune moment and been made to pay the hefty price for it.

Even though hands-free map guidance requires a phone nearby, the only sure way to avoid a penalty and a financial whack is to put phones out of sight of the driver and therefore Big Brother’s watchful eyes.

Fines for people using mobile phones while driving are propping up government coffers. Picture: Shutterstock.

The population’s errors have certainly swelled government coffers.

But are we really okay for this offence to be the same as the penalty for speeding between 30 and 40km/h over the speed limit?

Surely they are not always equitable in the risk of causing harm to others.

Taxes and fines are designed to curtail our behaviour and keep us in line.

But too often they create more problems and pain.

Dr Jane Stephens is a UniSC journalism lecturer, media commentator and writer.

Subscribe to SCN’s free daily news email

This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
[scn_go_back_button] Return Home
Share