Independent and FREE - 2021 Best Online Publication

PM’s words ‘mocked the presumption of innocence’

Independent and FREE – 2021 Best Online Publication (Qld Country Press)

PM’s words ‘mocked the presumption of innocence’

[pj-news-ticker]

Jane Stephens: PM's words mocked the presumption of innocence

Do you have a news tip? Click here to send to our news team.

Daredevil doctors put to the test in extreme conditions

Three new doctors have proved they have what it takes to practise medicine in the most extreme conditions. Whether it's dangling 250m above the sea, More

Buyers rush for slice as new neighbourhood opens

The southern Sunshine Coast’s newest waterfront community has officially opened at Pelican Waters, with only a handful of premium lots remaining. Castaways Pocket is nestled More

Why unusual nuggets are ‘flying off the shelves’

A Noosa mum has found the secret to encouraging kids to eat more 'plant-based' food — turn it into a nugget shape. Tammy Fry, from More

Esteemed architect behind iconic structure lifts the lid on Loo’s future

The award-winning architect behind Mooloolaba's iconic toilet block has given his view on the future of the 25-year-old weathered structure. Acclaimed Lindsay Clare designed the More

What’s happening inside opulent tent at Cotton Tree

A luxury travelling pavilion is set to excite and entertain crowds on the Sunshine Coast for the first time, during a 10-day festival. The Wonderland More

‘Time to laugh again’: Australia’s funniest people let loose on the Coast

A star-studded live comedy festival is coming to Caloundra this month and it promises to be "unscripted and dangerous". Growing up watching his own father More

There is a time to button your lips – a fact forgotten in this era of verbal diarrhoea and keyboard outpourings.

While the reasons for adopting a little shush can be led by etiquette, a need for social order or adherence to the law, when it comes to claims of sexual impropriety, so many from the top down seems to have opened the oral floodgates.

Claims of sexual abuse are accepted as true without question and the bloke (the accused is nearly always a man) is hung and quartered in the court of public opinion before he has had a chance to respond.

Seemingly, a woman’s claim to have been subject to unwanted advances, harassment or worse is instantly gospel without any need for corroboration or evidence.

But unless you gush loud support and strong condemnation of the accused, you are deemed to doubt the complainant.


To refrain is somehow construed as victim blaming – so much so that I write this with my breath slightly held.

It might be old fashioned to honour the pace and timing of the wheels of justice, but it is important.

Help keep independent and fair Sunshine Coast news and opinion coming by subscribing to our free daily news feed. All it requires is your name and email. See SUBSCRIBE at the top of this article 

A central plank of our system is that someone is innocent until proven guilty. A central thread in the fabric of our society is that we are all equal and should be treated as such.

But, as George Orwell pointed out in Animal Farm, it seems some are more equal than others.

‘Believe women’ is a slogan of the #metoo movement – but it is misunderstood.

It began as an attempt to redress appalling treatment of people who came forward to report sexual abuse, to indicate how endemic it is and how rare false claims of rape are.


But the phrase has come to mean ‘automatically believe women’ instead of ‘give women a fair hearing’.

Former Australian of the Year Grace Tame shared the National Press Club stage this month with Brittany Higgins, the woman who claimed on TV that she was raped in Parliament House three years ago after a big night out with workmates.

Her revelations led to a police investigation, an inquiry and a cultural overhaul in the House Under the Hill in Canberra.

A man was charged, but he denies the allegations absolutely.

As a result of the two women’s speeches, the PM apologised to Higgins for ‘the terrible things that took place’ that caused her ‘nightmare’.

Scott Morrison spoke in Parliament, which gives him absolute protection from prosecution over anything he said.

But his words mocked the presumption of innocence. It skipped over the rule of law that demands a fair and measured process be followed.


The effect is that this case is unlikely to be resolved anytime soon, with the accused’s legal team asking this week that the proceedings be put on hold.

The PM’s loose lips should act as a warning to us regular folk. We are not afforded the same protection as he is.

Sounding off about a person as if they are guilty without a court finding them to be so is primitive and downright unfair.

Silence does not imply consent, complicity or condone behaviour. It is simply lawful.

Jane Stephens is a USC journalism lecturer, media commentator and writer. The views expressed are her own.